Shares of Hindustan Aeronautics Ltd (HAL) continued their decline, dropping more than 3% despite the aerospace and defence firm announcing a revised Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) with the Aeronautical Development Agency (ADA) to enhance their collaboration on the LCA AF Mk-2 program.
HAL
Investor sentiment was dampened by a sales note from InCred, which highlighted valuation concerns within the defence sector, including HAL. InCred’s analysis compared HAL unfavorably with global peer Dassault Aviation. While Dassault reported revenue of $5.19 billion and a profit of $974 million in the last financial year, HAL recorded revenue of $3.67 billion with a profit of $921 million over the same period.
Despite these figures, HAL’s enterprise value stands at $41 billion, significantly higher than Dassault Aviation’s $6.7 billion.
The broader sell-off in defence stocks, including Bharat Dynamics (BDL), Bharat Electronics (BEL), and Paras Defence, further contributed to HAL’s downward trend, with these stocks falling up to 5%. Analysts attribute this recent decline to profit-taking and cautious sentiment ahead of the budget announcement.
Nirmal Bang recently downgraded HAL’s stock rating to ‘sell’ from ‘buy’, citing excessively high valuations and lowered its price target to Rs 4,380 from Rs 5,469. The brokerage noted that while it remains optimistic about the sector’s long-term prospects, current valuations do not adequately reflect risks such as rising raw material costs, competitive pressures, execution challenges, and cash flow dynamics.
On a positive note, Antique retained a ‘buy’ recommendation on defence stocks, including HAL, with a target price of Rs 6,145. The research firm highlighted government initiatives such as the development of defence corridors, increased FDI limits, and production-linked incentives (PLI) as favorable factors supporting the sector.
In summary, while structural positives exist for the defence sector, including strong government support and strategic initiatives, concerns over valuation and short-term market pressures have impacted HAL and other defence stocks in recent trading sessions.
